Captain America, Nazi

No, that’s not click bait. That’s Marvel’s latest move. They’re making Steve Rogers, Captain America since 1941, into an agent of Hydra, the Nazi organization of the Red Skull.

Now, I know what you’re thinking. If you read comic books, your first thought is that this must be: a clone / mind control / double agent / alternate reality / random comic gimmick here.

But no, they’ve said that is it 100% not that. It is Steve Rogers. The man we’ve known and loved for decades, has now, and has always been, a secret Nazi agent.

Marvel Executive Editor Tom Brevoort shed some light on the reveal, with USA Today citing him as telling them that this is “the real Steve Rogers,” and not “some clone, shapeshifting Skrull, Life Model Decoy or a Cap from an alternate universe.”

Speaking to Entertainment Weekly, writer Nick Spencer added to Brevoort’s statements that this is the real Steve, saying, “Issue 2 will lay a lot of our cards on the table in terms of what the new status quo is, but the one thing we can say unequivocally is: This is not a clone, not an imposter, not mind control, not someone else acting through Steve. This really is Steve Rogers, Captain America himself.”

“His mission is to further the goals and beliefs of Hydra,” explained Brevoort, back at USA Today, of Rogers’s new (or possibly old) secret status quo. “If that involves taking down the Marvel universe, sure. (But) it may not be as simple as that. It’s not like he’s exchanged his white hat for a black hat — it’s a green hat.”

So, the answer is “yes, really.”

To keep it clear: this is MARVEL COMICS. This is NOT Marvel Studios. This is not the movies. This is not the beloved Chris Evans. This is not the film that just came out. This is the comic book.

Which makes you wonder: who the hell green lit this?

Steve Rogers reveal

Now this shouldn’t be too much of a surprise to any and all concerned. After all, for the part few months, they’ve made Sam Wilson into the Captain America in the comics, and he is no longer the cool side kick, he’s been Captain Left-wing Agenda

So of course, Steve Rogers as Captain America must be a right-wing fascist in comparison. Nope, it’s not even “in comparison,” it’s just a fascist.

“We knew it would be like slapping people in the face,” confessed Brevoort. “The idea of Captain America means something very primal and very strong to the people of this nation, and they have a very visceral reaction when you get to something like that. You want people to feel and react to your story. So far, so good.”

So he knows it would offend people and did it anyway.

When did Marvel comics become so vile and corrupt that they cannot stand anything that looks like pure goodness? That they must be iconoclastic, even though they are smashing that which they made icons. I’m not suggesting that they are being iconoclastic without understanding what made him an icon. I’m suggesting that they know exactly what makes him an icon, and hate him because of that.

Noble? Can’t have that.

God-fearing? Can’t even use “the G-world.”

Patriotism? No. Sam Wilson as Captain America has shown us the way there. Every pro-life, pro-God, pro-Christian, pro-American anything is automatically an evil caricature.

Trusting in the inherent goodness of people in general and the American people in particular? People are evil and stupid, especially Americans.

You have to wonder how much hate these people must have for goodness that they resort to insulting their own fan base and destroying everything they’ve ever worked for in this fashion?

But it’s like John C. Wright once put in on a different topic,

“Such reckless hatred makes the hatred-eaten man his own victim, and makes his mind his own dungeon and torture chamber. He claws out his own entrails and gnaws them. All good things […] become, for him, a cause of malice and pain. Sunlight to him is darkness, and life is nightmare.
I begin to understand why so many of them speak of being frightened when no one menaces them, or of feeling unsafe when nothing threatens.”

Captain America — and there is only one Captain America — is chock full of virtues, in every meaning of the term. And now, at long last, Marvel Comics have come to the point where they cannot stand virtue, or goodness, unless it is on their own, narrowly defined terms.

Yes, the path to Heaven is also a straight and narrow path. But it looks like a superhighway compared to the “good leftists” of Marvel.

I am grateful, however, to Marvel comics for at least inspiring a good movie franchise before they decided to take their comics to the dogs. Right now, my major occupational goals include becoming a big enough writer to go to Marvel, ask to take over a character, and from there, slowly take over the entire Marvel comic universe. Because even at my worst, teenage drivel, I still could come up with better material than this.

About Declan Finn

Declan Finn is the author of Honor at Stake, an urban fantasy novel, nominated for Best Horror in the first annual Dragon Awards. He has also written The Pius Trilogy, an attempt to take Dan Brown to the woodshed in his own medium -- soon to be republished by Silver Empire Press. Finn has also written "Codename: Winterborn," an SF espionage thriller, and it's follow-up, "Codename: Winterborn." And "It was Only on Stun!" and "Set To Kill" are murder mysteries at a science fiction convention.
This entry was posted in Analysis, Commentary, Fiction, News, Rants, Superhero, Writing and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

15 Responses to Captain America, Nazi

  1. This is the worst thing ever. Not your comments — just the subject matter. Ugh.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. taarkoth says:

    Lord have mercy, this is bad if not worse than them having Spider-Man sacrifice the existence of his unborn daughter to the Devil in order to heal his decrepit, probably-going-to-keel-over-soon aunt of a simple gunshot wound.

    At least Peter Parker can claim temporary insanity due to grief.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. This is just more of the good-is-bad, bad-is-good “gray area” mentality of so much of today’s geek culture showing through once again. Actual heroes have been “uncool” and “bland” and too “black-and-white” in their morality for years among the non-Christian geeks I know (sadly, almost all of them). Often I will hear them discuss movies, games, TV etc. and a common thread among them is that they end up actively cheering for the villain because in their eyes the protagonist is an even bigger jerk (among other profane words). Doing what is right, according to them, is forcing the hero’s own agenda onto people, while the villain has his own motives, but apparently doesn’t force them onto people, even if he is going around killing, torturing and causing chaos. Care has been taken in a lot of places (most notably DC comics and films, in my mind) to craft interesting back stories for villains so much so that they become more interesting and sympathetic than the heroes to those sorts of geeks. The villain is someone we should be sorry for and the hero just doesn’t get it, in their view, because he’s too wrapped up in morality to figure it out. If they play paladins in D&D or Pathfinder, they tend to play them solely as a joke on the Lawful Good morality, mocking their own characters and their philosophies they must follow every step of the way. Most people I play with beg to become Chaotic Neutral because that’s the way many see the world: everyone should be able to do whatever they want and damn the consequences. God and justice get in their way. These guys wouldn’t dream of doing anything big that is wrong, like stealing something or killing someone, because they do have their own standards of decency they follow, but they hate people placing an overarching standard of decency on them. They see anti-heroes, such as Deadpool, as great because an anti-hero doesn’t walk the path of “good” or “evil”, just their own interests. It doesn’t hurt that anti-heroes often use the foul language and dirty joking attitudes so over-abundantly used by geek culture today (I enjoy some less-than-clean humor every once in a while, but do we really need to get to the point that most geeky YouTube videos are dropping F-bombs every other sentence?). So, in short, Cap’s turning is just Marvel attempting a further reflection of what has apparently been so popular in geek culture lately: as they say in Assassin’s Creed, “Nothing is true, everything is permitted”. (Heck, Assassin’s Creed is another good example – Connor is the least favorite protagonist of most fans because they call him “bland” – perhaps they mean because Connor actually had morals and fought for what is right, compared to Altair or Ezio?)

    Liked by 3 people

    • Ross Windsor says:

      Yeah, I’ve never understood the negativity towards the Lawful Good alignment. They are the characters I find the most fun to play and write about. They make tough choices and live with the consequences; they’re the ones who are fair and good simply because it’s the right thing to do. Most people think their character flaw is going to extremes, and sometimes that is the case, but more often the flaw for a Lawful Good character is a fear of making the wrong choice, which can lead to inaction, which causes more problems, and so on and so on. It’s spurs on such complex, dynamic stories, AND PEOPLE CALL THEM BLAND?!?!

      Captain America may be the best (and most awesome) example of a Lawful Good hero, but you know who else shares that alignment? Frickin’ Batman! Anyone want to call HIM boring or bland?

      Liked by 2 people

      • Foxfier says:

        Most of the good superheroes are lawful good, barring Author Stupidity.

        The Flash, for example, is not just lawful good, but lawful nice— he could be so incredibly scary…..

        Liked by 1 person

  4. Foxfier says:

    So he knows it would offend people and did it anyway.

    No, he did it BECAUSE it would offend people.

    Which means he’s scum.

    Liked by 4 people

  5. Foxfier says:

    Am I the only one creepered out by the guy basically going “Yeah, he’s a Nazi member of a destroy-everybody hardline Nazi group you gotta try to get into, but he’s not a bad Nazi!”

    White wash Nazis much?

    Liked by 2 people

  6. pops1918 says:

    When I started seeing this headline crop up, my first impression was that Marvel was officially out of ideas. Looks like I wasn’t far wrong.

    Ultimately, it’s Mass Effect 3 all over again: their IP, they get to decide how to tell their story. By the same token, though, when they tell a bad story, I have zero obligation to like it or continue to listen – and chances are, there’s someone out there willing to tell a story I *do* like instead.


  7. JD Cowan says:

    He could always make a deal with the devil to go back the way he was.

    These are modern (stupid) comics, after all.

    Liked by 2 people

  8. Thomas McGee says:

    Well this will kill sales of older Golden, Silver, and Bronze age comics.


  9. Fen Needwood says:

    People should troll Marvel and ask them why they are trying to normalize Nazis.

    Liked by 2 people

  10. Pingback: Marvel writer defends making Captain America a Nazi

  11. Amen! Thank you so much for saying this!!! It is music to my ears!!!

    Did you hear what the Marvel VP of sales, David Gabriel, said in March? He got everybody in an uproar by saying that comic sales have dropped because people don’t want any more diversity or women in Marvel’s new comics. As if Marvel has ever lacked for either type of characters from its inception! Mr. Finn, if you DO get into Marvel and take over a character, please remember that there are plenty of other people who would like a shot at cleaning up the company, too! Get that foot in the door, and you will have an army of fans pouring through it to back you up in the fight!


    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to Ross Windsor Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s